Mandamus decisions / District of New Mexico
Villegas v. Holder et al.
What the decision decided
Each value cites the passage it was read from. Values read by a model were checked against that passage; values read by rule come from fixed text patterns. Read the decision before relying on either.
| Agency |
USCIS
Read by rule
the Court process his application for citizenship or remand the case to the United States Citizen & Immigration Service (“USCIS”) to have USCIS process his application. (Doc. 1). |
|---|---|
| Form or filing |
N-400 (naturalization)
Read by rule
seeks to have the Court process his application for citizenship or remand the case to the United States Citizen & Immigration Service (“USCIS”) to have USCIS process his application. (Doc. 1). |
| Motion decided |
Motion to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction
Read by rule
12(b)(1), |
| Disposition | Magistrate judge's recommendation A magistrate judge's report and recommendation. The district judge decides whether to adopt it, so it is not counted as either side's win. Read by rule |
| Prevailing party | Neither side Read by rule |
How the case ended
- Docket
- No. 2:10-cv-01108
- Filed
- November 15, 2010
- Ended
- June 14, 2011
- Suit's filing to its end
- 211 days
- How it ended
- Dismissed on jurisdiction or the merits
- From the record
- Federal court records: judgment on a motion before trial, for the government
A voluntary or stipulated dismissal is how most suits end once the agency acts; the docket rarely says why.
Supreme Court and Tenth Circuit authority
District decisions bind no one. On the questions this decision raises, the Supreme Court decisions and the circuit's published decisions listed here bind this court; a circuit disposition marked nonprecedential was not published as precedent and is persuasive only. ImmCite status as read November 22, 2026. Check the current status before relying on one.
-
Norton v. Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance, 542 U.S. 55
Supreme Court, June 14, 2004. Section 706(1) and mandamus reach only a discrete agency action that the agency is legally required to take, so a court cannot compel programmatic improvements or action the law leaves to agency discretion.
ImmCite: treatment available, history exists, not clearance
-
Al-Maleki v. Holder, 558 F.3d 1200
Tenth Circuit, March 18, 2009. A § 1447(b) remand ordering USCIS to administer the oath by a date certain is enforceable merits relief, and the government's request for an open-ended remand after missing the 120-day deadline was not substantially justified.
ImmCite: treatment available, history exists, not clearance. ImmCite has read all 3 published decisions citing this case, as of 2026-11-16; none treats it adversely. That describes those decisions; it is not a determination that the case is good law.
-
Forest Guardians v. Babbitt, 174 F.3d 1178
Tenth Circuit, April 22, 1999. Missing a concrete statutory deadline is agency action unlawfully withheld that a court must compel, while without a deadline the question is unreasonable delay; the holding still binds in the Tenth Circuit.
ImmCite: caution, adverse or limiting treatment found. Reasoning rejected (historical) by Al Otro Lado v. Noem, 138 F.4th 1102 (2025).
About this collection
3,149 written decisions from 2,869 cases in the whole mandamus and agency-delay group, the group's newest decided November 20, 2026. Updated November 21, 2026 at 7:58 p.m. CT. Of the 1,648 public decisions since January 1, 2025 that a CourtListener and GovInfo search for agency delay finds, Passim holds 1,439 (87%), 1,058 of them in this group, measured November 21, 2026. Tell us about a decision we're missing.
This page reports one past decision. It is not a prediction of how any case will be decided.