Judges / New York, NY (NYB)

James M. McCarthy

Immigration judge. EOIR's case data records 5,782 proceedings completed by Judge James M. McCarthy from 2022 through 2026 (October 2026 release), more of them at the New York, NY (NYB) immigration court than at any other.

Also at Buffalo, NY (225), New York, NY (NYC) (73).

These are counts of past decisions, not a forecast for any case. A judge's rates follow the cases that reach the judge: whether people are detained, whether they have a representative and where they are from. This page shows that mix and gives the court's and the country's figures for the same period beside the judge's.

Asylum decisions The cases behind the rates How removal proceedings ended Other relief Appeals

Asylum decisions

Proceedings from 2022 through 2026 (October 2026 release) in which the judge granted or denied an application for asylum, withholding of removal or protection under the Convention Against Torture. Each proceeding counts once. The first row counts the newest twelve months of the data alone, October 2025 through September 2026, and the rows under it count the whole period. Grant rates change from year to year, as the table by year shows, so the two can differ widely.

Judge James M. McCarthyNew York, NY (NYB), all judgesAll courts
Asylum granted, October 2025 through September 20269%26 of 27610%482 of 5,0396%10,593 of 163,396
Asylum granted, 2022 through 202636%337 of 94531%7,847 of 25,40926%134,312 of 516,367
Decided on the merits94525,409516,367
Withholding of removal or Convention Against Torture protection granted, asylum not granted4%40 of 9454%985 of 25,4093%17,541 of 516,367
Denied60%568 of 94565%16,577 of 25,40971%364,514 of 516,367
Left out of the rates: no grant or denial recorded, or a record that can't be classified1,99541,4201,333,215
Average time from a proceeding's start in court to its completion, for proceedings with one of these applications2.7 years2.2 years2.8 years

By year

YearProceedings completedAsylum decisionsAsylum grantedOther protection grantedDenied
2026partial year1,2672188%17 of 2183%7 of 21889%194 of 218
20251,27125623%58 of 2568%20 of 25670%178 of 256
20241,38917139%67 of 1713%5 of 17158%99 of 171
20231,08615859%93 of 1584%7 of 15837%58 of 158
202276914272%102 of 1421%1 of 14227%39 of 142

The cases behind the rates

Who was before the judge in the asylum decisions above, and how often asylum was granted in each group, with the same group across the New York, NY (NYB) court. Custody is the status EOIR's data records for the case. A representative's appearance is EOIR's case-level record (form EOIR-28); it doesn't show whether the representative was there when the judge decided.

Share of the judge's decisionsAsylum granted: Judge James M. McCarthyAsylum granted: New York, NY (NYB), all judges
A representative's appearance on the case record93%875 of 94537%327 of 87535%7,337 of 20,913
No representative's appearance on the case record7%70 of 94514%10 of 7011%510 of 4,496
Detained1%14 of 9451 of 142%6 of 292
Released from detention15%141 of 94539%55 of 14145%1,280 of 2,872
Never detained84%790 of 94536%281 of 79029%6,561 of 22,244

Most common nationalities

DecisionsAsylum granted: Judge James M. McCarthyAsylum granted: all courts
Guinea9524%23 of 9533%1,055 of 3,194
Senegal936%6 of 9311%397 of 3,759
Ecuador8313%11 of 8312%3,466 of 29,411
China7575%56 of 7560%13,438 of 22,264
Honduras5342%22 of 5314%7,354 of 51,617
India5342%22 of 5344%9,970 of 22,587

How removal proceedings ended

How the removal proceedings the judge completed from 2022 through 2026 (October 2026 release) ended. The percentages are of the proceedings a judge decided; a case that is sent back and decided again counts each time. Proceedings that left the court without a decision are counted below them and are outside the percentages.

Judge James M. McCarthyNew York, NY (NYB), all judgesAll courts
Removal proceedings decided by a judge3,91193,4663,238,452
Ordered removed, not in absentia21%809 of 3,91125%23,075 of 93,46621%684,814 of 3,238,452
Ordered removed in absentia: EOIR's data marks that the person did not appear39%1,520 of 3,91140%37,654 of 93,46637%1,199,277 of 3,238,452
Ordered removed, with withholding of removal or Convention Against Torture protection granted1%38 of 3,9111%824 of 93,466under 1%12,079 of 3,238,452
Voluntary departure2%96 of 3,9111%1,237 of 93,4665%158,922 of 3,238,452
Relief granted11%425 of 3,91110%9,314 of 93,4666%183,056 of 3,238,452
Terminated2%61 of 3,9114%3,482 of 93,46611%367,144 of 3,238,452
Dismissed by the judge25%962 of 3,91119%17,864 of 93,46619%630,482 of 3,238,452
Another decision0%0 of 3,911under 1%16 of 93,466under 1%2,678 of 3,238,452
Moved to another court: change of venue or transfer1,43025,0001,357,095
Failure to prosecute, EOIR's completion code for cases DHS did not pursue2209,004371,674
Administratively closed, or completed another way without a decision1852,639166,831
Other kinds of case, such as credible-fear reviews, not broken down here36525184,543

Other relief

Applications other than asylum that the judge granted or denied from 2022 through 2026 (October 2026 release). A proceeding counts once for each kind of relief decided in it.

DecidedGranted: Judge James M. McCarthyGranted: New York, NY (NYB), all judgesGranted: all courts
Cancellation of removal for non-permanent residents6277%48 of 6246%334 of 73042%19,545 of 46,533
Cancellation of removal for permanent residents43 of 477%37 of 4858%3,427 of 5,921
Adjustment of status109 of 1094%338 of 35881%17,553 of 21,557
Waivers44 of 490%79 of 8876%3,363 of 4,420
Voluntary departure9997%96 of 9999%1,240 of 1,25680%158,908 of 197,860

Appeals to the Board of Immigration Appeals

Appeals EOIR's data links to the proceedings the judge completed in this period, whichever side appealed. Some appeals are tied to a case and not to one proceeding; those are counted with the newest proceeding in the case, so a few may concern another judge's decision. A remand sends a case back for more proceedings and is not a count of errors. Appeals from the newest years may still be pending, so their outcomes will change.

Judge James M. McCarthyNew York, NY (NYB), all judgesAll courts
Proceedings completed5,782130,6345,318,595
Appealed to the Board11%631 of 5,78213%16,881 of 130,6346%340,895 of 5,318,595
Appeals the Board has decided565,14284,492
Sent back to the immigration court (remanded)11%6 of 565%270 of 5,14211%9,204 of 84,492
Dismissed or denied, with or without voluntary departure39%22 of 5662%3,179 of 5,14253%44,777 of 84,492
Appeals still pending57611,828260,818

Counted by Passim from EOIR's case data, the release of October 1, 2026. A percentage is given only over at least 30 decisions; smaller groups show their counts alone. How these figures are counted.